| | | Northwood wins toss and defers; UIndy will defend South Goal. |
| | | Chris Kollias kickoff 65 yards to the UI0, touchback. |
| H | 1-10 | H20 | Craig Jenkins rush for 9 yards to the UI29 (Richard Davis), PENALTY NU offside declined. |
| H | 2-1 | H29 | Casey Gillin rush for 2 yards to the UI31, 1ST DOWN UI (Richard Davis;Kyle Clement). |
| H | 1-10 | H31 | Craig Jenkins rush for 14 yards to the UI45, 1ST DOWN UI (Jon Horn). |
| H | 1-10 | H45 | Craig Jenkins rush for 1 yard to the UI46 (Cortez McCoy). |
| H | 2-9 | H46 | Marcus Nalley rush for 5 yards to the NU49 (C. Hughes). |
| H | 3-4 | V49 | Casey Gillin pass incomplete to Sam Elmore, dropped pass. |
| H | 4-4 | V49 | Tyran Fakes punt 21 yards to the NU28, downed. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 31 yards, TOP 03:14 |
| V | 1-10 | V28 | NORTHWOOD drive start at 11:46 (1st). |
| V | 1-10 | V28 | NU ball on NU29. |
| V | 1-10 | V29 | Torris Childs rush for 1 yard to the NU30 (Jamel Williams). |
| V | 2-9 | V30 | Torris Childs rush for 3 yards to the NU33 (James Wood;Mychal Byrd). |
| V | 3-6 | V33 | Casey Steffen rush for 6 yards to the NU39, 1ST DOWN NU (Leonard Bush;Kevin Shaw). |
| V | 1-10 | V39 | Kyle Kolbe rush for 2 yards to the NU41 (B. Umphress;Jimmy Fleshman). |
| V | 2-8 | V41 | Kyle Kolbe pass incomplete to Josh Rauser. |
| V | 3-8 | V41 | Torris Childs rush for 3 yards to the NU44 (Mychal Byrd). |
| V | 4-5 | V44 | Chris Kollias punt 56 yards to the UI0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 15 yards, TOP 03:27 |
| H | 1-10 | H20 | INDIANAPOLIS drive start at 08:19 (1st). |
| H | 1-10 | H20 | Casey Gillin pass complete to Kevin Sanford for 7 yards to the UI27 (Quincy Burts;Eugene Smith). |
| H | 2-3 | H27 | Craig Jenkins rush for 2 yards to the UI29 (Richard Davis). |
| H | 3-1 | H29 | Craig Jenkins rush for 2 yards to the UI31, 1ST DOWN UI (Jon Horn;Cortez McCoy). |
| H | 1-10 | H31 | Craig Jenkins rush for no gain to the UI31 (Chris Burgess). |
| H | 2-10 | H31 | PENALTY UI delay of game 5 yards to the UI26. |
| H | 2-15 | H26 | Casey Gillin pass complete to Sam Elmore for 23 yards to the UI49, 1ST DOWN UI (Jon Horn). |
| H | 1-10 | H49 | Casey Gillin sacked for loss of 9 yards to the UI40 (C. Hughes). |
| H | 2-19 | H40 | Casey Gillin pass incomplete to Craig Jenkins, QB hurry by Bahrar Faik. |
| H | 3-19 | H40 | Casey Gillin pass complete to Stephen Geller for 17 yards to the NU43, out-of-bounds. |
| H | 4-2 | V43 | Tyran Fakes punt 23 yards to the NU20, fair catch by Jon Horn. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 37 yards, TOP 03:54 |
| V | 1-10 | V20 | NORTHWOOD drive start at 04:25 (1st). |
| V | 1-10 | V20 | Kyle Kolbe pass incomplete to Antonie Carr. |
| V | 2-10 | V20 | Antonie Ivy rush for loss of 6 yards to the NU14 (Josh Kimbowa). |
| V | 3-16 | V14 | Kyle Kolbe pass complete to Antonie Carr for 10 yards to the NU24 (James Wood;Neimiah Simons). |
| V | 4-6 | V24 | Chris Kollias punt 45 yards to the UI31, Jason Clinton return 13 yards to the UI44 (Antraz Burton;Steve Learman). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 4 yards, TOP 02:17 |
| H | 1-10 | H44 | INDIANAPOLIS drive start at 02:08 (1st). |
| H | 1-10 | H44 | Craig Jenkins rush for 6 yards to the 50 yardline (Cortez McCoy;Matt Worton). |
| H | 2-4 | H50 | Craig Jenkins rush for no gain to the 50 yardline (Richard Davis;Eric Stevens). |
| H | 3-4 | H50 | Casey Gillin pass incomplete to Stephen Geller. |
| H | 4-4 | H50 | Tyran Fakes punt 28 yards to the NU22, fair catch by Jon Horn. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 6 yards, TOP 01:57 |
| V | 1-10 | V22 | NORTHWOOD drive start at 00:11 (1st). |
| V | 1-10 | V22 | NU ball on NU23. |
| | | Northwood 0, Indianapolis 0 |