| V | 1-10 | V23 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| V | 1-10 | V23 | Kyle Kolbe rush for 1 yard to the NU24 (Mychal Byrd). |
| V | 2-9 | V24 | Kyle Kolbe rush for 8 yards to the NU32 (Leonard Bush). |
| V | 3-1 | V32 | Harry Agee rush for 8 yards to the NU40, 1ST DOWN NU (Leonard Bush). |
| V | 1-10 | V40 | PENALTY UI unsportsmanlike conduct 15 yards to the UI45, 1ST DOWN NU. |
| V | 1-10 | H45 | PENALTY UI unsportsmanlike conduct 15 yards to the UI30, 1ST DOWN NU. |
| V | 1-10 | H30 | Torris Childs rush for 4 yards to the UI26 (James Wood;Trent Harris). |
| V | 2-6 | H26 | Harry Agee rush for loss of 1 yard to the UI27. |
| V | 3-7 | H27 | Kyle Kolbe rush for 4 yards to the UI23 (Kevin Shaw;James Wood). |
| V | 4-3 | H23 | Antonie Ivy rush for 5 yards to the UI18, 1ST DOWN NU (John Adams;Kevin Shaw). |
| V | 1-10 | H18 | Antonie Ivy rush for 4 yards to the UI14 (Kevin Shaw). |
| V | 2-6 | H14 | Kyle Kolbe rush for 11 yards to the UI3, 1ST DOWN NU (Kevin Shaw). |
| V | 1-G | H03 | Antonie Ivy rush for 1 yard to the UI2 (Neimiah Simons;Kevin Shaw). |
| V | 2-G | H02 | Kyle Kolbe rush for 2 yards to the UI0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 10:42. |
| | | Chris Kollias kick attempt good. |
| | | Northwood 7, Indianapolis 0 |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 77 yards, TOP 04:29 |
| | | Chris Kollias kickoff 42 yards to the UI23, Marcus Nalley return 5 yards to the UI28 (Bryce Rucker;Phillip Davis). |
| H | 1-10 | H28 | INDIANAPOLIS drive start at 10:32 (2nd). |
| H | 1-10 | H28 | Craig Jenkins rush for no gain to the UI28 (C. Hughes;Richard Davis). |
| H | 2-10 | H28 | Casey Gillin pass complete to Sam Elmore for 7 yards to the UI35 (Cortez McCoy). |
| H | 3-3 | H35 | Casey Gillin pass complete to Sam Elmore for no gain to the UI35 (Jon Horn). |
| H | 4-3 | H35 | Tyran Fakes punt -16 yards to the UI19, Jon Horn return to the NU30 (Bahrar Faik), PENALTY NU roughing the kicker 5 yards to the UI40, 1ST DOWN UI, NO PLAY. |
| H | 1-10 | H40 | Craig Jenkins rush for loss of 3 yards to the UI37 (Kyle Clement). |
| H | 2-13 | H37 | Casey Gillin pass complete to Stephen Geller for 18 yards to the NU45, 1ST DOWN UI (Dexter Reid). |
| H | 1-10 | V45 | Casey Gillin pass complete to Kevin Sanford for 7 yards to the NU38 (Dexter Reid;Cortez McCoy). |
| H | 2-3 | V38 | Craig Jenkins rush for no gain to the NU38 (Richard Davis). |
| H | 3-3 | V38 | Casey Gillin pass incomplete to Lance Lasker (Mike Rogers). |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 34 yards, TOP 05:13 |
| | | Tyran Fakes kickoff 38 yards to the NU0, touchback. |
| V | 1-10 | V20 | NORTHWOOD drive start at 05:19 (2nd). |
| V | 1-10 | V20 | Torris Childs rush for 3 yards to the NU23 (Jamel Williams). |
| V | 2-7 | V23 | Torris Childs rush for 2 yards to the NU25 (Jimmy Fleshman). |
| V | 3-5 | V25 | Casey Steffen rush for 7 yards to the NU32, 1ST DOWN NU (Kenneth Akridge;Kevin Shaw). |
| V | 1-10 | V32 | Kyle Kolbe rush for 3 yards to the NU35 (Leonard Bush;Kevin Shaw). |
| V | 2-7 | V35 | Kyle Kolbe rush for 12 yards to the NU47, 1ST DOWN NU (Neimiah Simons). |
| V | 1-10 | V47 | Kyle Kolbe pass incomplete to Phillip Davis (Kevin Shaw), PENALTY NU illegal procedure 5 yards to the NU42, NO PLAY. |
| V | 1-15 | V42 | Kyle Kolbe rush for 3 yards to the NU45 (Kevin Shaw). |
| V | 2-12 | V45 | Torris Childs rush for 2 yards to the NU47 (Jimmy Fleshman). |
| V | 3-10 | V47 | Timeout Indianapolis, clock 01:26. |
| V | 3-10 | V47 | Kyle Kolbe rush for loss of 2 yards to the NU45 (Alex Byrnes;Jimmy Fleshman). |
| V | 4-12 | V45 | Timeout Indianapolis, clock 01:20. |
| V | 4-12 | V45 | Chris Kollias punt 33 yards to the UI22, downed. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 25 yards, TOP 04:07 |
| H | 1-10 | H22 | INDIANAPOLIS drive start at 01:12 (2nd). |
| H | 1-10 | H22 | Casey Gillin pass complete to Kevin Sanford for 8 yards to the UI30 (Jon Horn). |
| H | 2-2 | H30 | Casey Gillin pass complete to Stephen Geller for 8 yards to the UI38, out-of-bounds, PENALTY UI ineligible downfield on pass 5 yards to the UI25, NO PLAY. |
| H | 2-7 | H25 | Casey Gillin pass incomplete to Albert Spears, dropped pass. |
| H | 3-7 | H25 | Casey Gillin pass complete to Kevin Sanford for 2 yards to the UI27 (Jon Horn). |
| H | 4-5 | H27 | Timeout Northwood, clock 00:25. |
| H | 4-5 | H27 | Tyran Fakes punt 51 yards to the NU22, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 5 yards, TOP 00:59 |
| V | 1-10 | V22 | NORTHWOOD drive start at 00:13 (2nd). |
| V | 1-10 | V22 | End of 1st half, clock 00:00. |